Saturday, July 16, 2005
This day in history from:

The Truth about Truth Commissions

We all have been hearing all this clamor for a truth commission...

But what is this truth commission and what does it hope to accomplish?

The most famous world experience is South Africa's Truth and Reconciliation Commission, established after their apartheid era.

According to documents readily available on the web, as history teaches us, South Africa was reeling from deeply cultural, societal, political and legal division during that time and their truth commission was established. Hence, the Truth and Reconcilation Commission was established under South Africa's Promotion of National Unity and Reconciliation Act No. 34 of 1995.

Its truth commission laid down a process where an applicant "was released from all criminal and civil liability arising from the incident, an indemnification that also extended to all institutions or persons who incurred vicarious liability for the incident. Successful applicants serving prison sentences in respect of an incident were, therefore, entitled to immediate release and the expunging of any relevant criminal record," in exchange for full disclosure of their actions /participation in the crimes they have committed during the repression era.

This is not that way I want our truth commission to go. I don't want the people involved here, the President included, to go scott free. I don't want this Truth Commission of ours to be merely fact finding. Sorry, HEADS MUST ROLL for this one.

I would prefer something like the Office of the Independent Counsel in the United States.

In 1978, Congress passed, and President Carter signed into law, the Ethics in Government Act. Title VI of this Act created the Independent Counsel, changing the way that high-ranking government officials were held responsible for their actions. If the Attorney General receives information indicating that a high-ranking official has committed a crime, thirty days are given to determine whether or not the information is both specific and reliable. If determined to be so, then a preliminary investigation begins, during which very limited powers are exercised. (The Attorney General cannot convene a grand jury, offer plea bargains, grant immunity, or subpoena witnesses.).

After ninety days, the Attorney General must decide whether or not further investigation is warranted, and if it is, must apply to a federal three-judge panel to appoint and determine the jurisdiction of an Independent Counsel.
This three-judge panel is appointed every two years by the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court.

The Counsel's jurisdiction is expandable and includes "the authority to investigate and prosecute Federal crimes, other than those classified as Class B or C misdemeanors or infractions, that may arise out of the investigation or prosecution of the matter with respect to which the Attorney General's request was made, including perjury, obstruction of justice, destruction of evidence, and intimidation of witnesses."


The Independent Counsel has the full authority of a federal prosecutor and full access to Justice Department resources (including the use of the FBI, etc.). In addition, the prosecutor is expected to comply with Justice Department prosecutorial guidelines.
Unless convicted in impeachment proceedings, the Independent Counsel can only be removed from office by the Attorney General, and "only for good cause, physical or mental disability . . . or any other condition that substantially impairs the performance of such independent counsel's duties."

Finally, the Independent Counsel law must be renewed by Congress every five years or it expires (although, if it is allowed to expire, any ongoing investigations are completed). (from The Independent Counsel After Nixon by Josh Chafetz in the The Yale Political Quarterly Volume 19, Number 3, April 1998, taken from this link)


I know the rationale behind Presidential immunity and the removal only by process of impeachment. This was instituted to prevent the President from devoting most of his time fending off made-up cases from opponents rathen than concentrating on running the country. Sadly, this political and legal immunity has been abused of late. The President must be more accountable now than ever.

Whatever it is, something must be done. It cannot go on like this.

There is a joke Justice Venicio Escolin, our teacher in Remedial Law, used to tell us.

"When you are strong in the law, weak on the facts, you pound on the law...
When you are strong on the facts and weak on the law, you pound of the facts...
When you are weak on both, you pound on the table!"

The Philippines is weak on both in this regard. Don't let the Filipino people use you as the table...

My two cents...

0 Objection(s):

Post a Comment

<< Home

Disaster relief, sustainable development & community service


Featured PinoyBlog of the Week

Side Prayers

PRAYER FOR GENEROSITY
Lord Jesus,
Teach me to be generous,
Teach me to serve You as You deserve
To give and not to count the cost,
To fight and not to heed the wounds,
To toil and not to seek for rest,
To labor and not to ask for reward,
except that of knowing
That I do Your Holy Will. Amen

THE LAWYER'S PRAYER
May every word I speak be from Your Truth...
I ask come from Your Wisdom...
May every case I handle receive Your Guidance...
May every heart, every life I touch, feel Your Love.

THE JABEZ PRAYER
And Jabez called on the God of Israel saying,
"Oh, that You would bless me indeed,
and enlarge my territory,
that Your Hand be with me,
that You would keep me from evil,
that I may not cause pain."

So God granted him what he requested.

Side Oath

The Lawyer's Oath
I do solemnly swear that
I will maintain allegiance to
the Republic of the Philippines,
I will support its Constitution
and obey the laws as well as
the legal orders of the
duly constituted authorities therein;
I will do no falsehood,
nor consent to the doing of any in court;
I will not wittingly or willingly
promote or sue any groundless,
false or unlawful suit,
nor give aid nor consent to the same;
I will delay no man for money or malice,
and will conduct myself as a lawyer
according to the best of my knowledge
and discretion with all good fidelity
as well to the courts as to my clients;
and I impose upon myself this voluntary obligation
without any mental reservation
or purpose of evasion.
So help me God.

Side Chatter

Add me to Skype

Noel Punzi Eustaquio Punzalan's Facebook profile

Tagontheside

Blog Lectures

Side Blog Roll

Blogroll Me!

Shameless Sideplugs

Powered by Blogger





A Pinoy Blogger

Get Firefox!











Bored Single Bloggers Club



My blog is worth $35,566.02.
How much is your blog worth?

<a href="http://www.bloginspace.com/" target="_blank"><img src="http://www.bloginspace.com/_assets/img/badges/bloginspace_145x100.gif" width="145" height="100" border="0" alt="BlogInSpace.com"></a>

 

Image hosted by Photobucket.com

Technorati search

eXTReMe Tracker

Enter your Email


Powered by FeedBlitz

Get Firefox!

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.

in/out sider(s) online
Casino

Mesothelioma Lawsuit
mesothelioma

Who Links Here